Essential Puppy Training Questions Answered
The Complete FAQ Guide

Picture this: Your puppy is zooming around the park, ignoring your calls to 'come,' while you wonder if all your training efforts were for nothing. Or maybe your once-perfect 'sit' command now gets you nothing but a blank stare. Sound familiar? You’re not alone. Since publishing our two-part series on essential puppy training commands, we’ve received hundreds of questions from new puppy owners just like you, navigating the rollercoaster of dog training.

The truth is, every puppy is unique, and even the most comprehensive training guide can't predict every scenario you'll encounter. That's why we've compiled this extensive FAQ addressing the most common concerns, frustrations, and roadblocks our readers experience during their training journey. These aren't theoretical problems – they're real situations reported by real puppy parents who are working through the same challenges you might be facing right now.

Essential Puppy Training - Whether you're just starting with foundational commands or working through the advanced safety commands, this FAQ serves as your troubleshooting companion. Many of these questions arise because puppy training rarely goes exactly as planned. Your brilliant puppy who sits perfectly in the kitchen might act like they've never heard the word "sit" when you're at the park. Your eager student who mastered "stay" in three days might suddenly develop selective hearing during week four. This is all completely normal!

We've organized these questions to address both the foundation commands (name recognition, sit, stay) and the advanced commands (come, down, leave it, wait) covered in our training series. But here's what's important: if you're struggling with issues covered in these FAQs, it often indicates that you should actively work through both Part 1: "Foundation Puppy Training: Building Blocks for Success" and Part 2: "Advanced Puppy Commands: Safety and Real-World Training" of our comprehensive training series. These articles provide the detailed step-by-step guidance that supports the troubleshooting advice you'll find below.

Think of this FAQ as your training companion – a resource to return to when you hit bumps in the road or need quick clarification on common challenges. Puppy training is a journey, not a destination, and having reliable answers to your questions can make the difference between frustration and success. Remember, the fact that you're seeking answers and solutions shows you're exactly the kind of dedicated puppy parent who will succeed in building a strong, communicative relationship with your new family member.

What You’ll Find in This FAQ

• Foundation Commands: Solutions for name recognition, sit, and stay.
• Advanced Commands: Tips for mastering come, down, leave it, and wait.
• Common Frustrations: Why your puppy forgets commands or ignores you in new environments."

Let's dive into the questions that matter most to you and your puppy's training journey.

General Training Questions

Q: My puppy is 5 months old. Is it too late to start training these basic commands?

A: It's never too late! While the 8-16 week window is optimal for learning, older puppies can absolutely master these commands. You might need slightly longer training sessions (8-10 minutes instead of 5) and more patience, but 5-month-old puppies often have better attention spans than very young ones. Start with the same foundation and progress at your puppy's pace.

Q: How long should it take my puppy to learn each command?

A: Most puppies can learn "sit" within 3-7 days of consistent practice. Name recognition typically takes 1-2 weeks to become reliable. "Stay" is more challenging and may take 2-3 weeks to achieve even short stays. Remember, "learning" means responding reliably in various environments, not just performing once in your living room. Be patient – every puppy progresses differently.

Q: My puppy knows the commands at home but ignores them outside. What's wrong?

A: Nothing's wrong! This is completely normal and called "lack of generalization." Puppies don't automatically understand that "sit" in the kitchen means the same thing as "sit" in the park. You need to retrain each command in new environments, starting with minimal distractions and gradually building up. Think of it as expanding their vocabulary rather than starting over.

Q: Should I train my puppy every day?

A: Yes, but not in formal sessions every day. Aim for 3-4 structured training sessions per week, but practice commands informally every day during normal activities. Use "sit" before meals, practice name recognition throughout the day, and reinforce "stay" at doorways. This daily integration is more valuable than perfect formal sessions.

Name Recognition Questions

Q: My puppy looks at me when I say their name, but then immediately looks away. Is this normal?

A: Yes, brief attention is normal at first! Young puppies have very short attention spans. Reward even 1-2 seconds of eye contact initially, then gradually expect longer attention as they mature. Don't try to hold their gaze too long at first – this can feel intimidating to some puppies.

Q: I've been using my puppy's name a lot throughout the day. Could this be why they're not responding during training?

A: Possibly. If you use their name constantly for everything (including negative situations), it becomes background noise. Try using their name only when you want their attention, and practice the name recognition exercise specifically. Reserve their name for positive interactions and important communications.

Q: Should I use a nickname or their full name for training?

A: Choose one name and stick with it consistently. Whether it's "Buddy" or "Buckingham Palace," consistency matters more than the specific name. All family members should use the same name during training. You can use nicknames casually, but training should use one consistent identifier.

"Sit" Command Questions

Q: My puppy sits, but then immediately stands up. How do I make them stay sitting?
A: This is actually normal for the "sit" command alone – "sit" just means "put your bottom on the ground," not "stay there forever." If you want them to remain sitting, you'll need to add the "stay" command. For now, reward the sit immediately when their bottom touches the ground, even if they stand right back up.

Q: My puppy sits but it's crooked or sloppy. Should I correct this?

A: Not at this stage! Focus on getting the behavior reliably first. A crooked sit is still a sit. Once your puppy responds consistently to the "sit" command, you can work on improving the position by only rewarding straighter sits. But for foundation training, any bottom-on-ground position counts as success.

Q: My puppy won't sit unless I have treats. Is this a problem?

A: This is normal in early training, but you should gradually reduce treat dependency. Once your puppy sits reliably with treats, start intermittent reinforcement – reward every 2nd sit, then every 3rd, and so on. Replace food rewards with praise and petting sometimes. The goal is a puppy who sits because you asked, not just for treats.

"Stay" Command Questions

Q: How long should my puppy be able to stay by the end of the first two weeks?

A: Don't focus on duration initially – focus on the concept. A successful 3-second stay with you one step away is excellent progress for a young puppy. By the end of two weeks of consistent practice, aim for 10-15 seconds at 3-4 feet distance. Long stays come later with maturity and practice.

Q: My puppy breaks the stay when I move. What am I doing wrong?

A: You're probably increasing distance too quickly. Go back to one small step away and build success there first. Also, make sure you're returning to your puppy to release them rather than calling them to come to you – coming to you breaks the stay. Always go back to them and say "okay" to release.

Q: Should I correct my puppy when they break a stay?

A: No corrections needed! Simply say "oops" in a neutral tone, guide them back to the original position, and try an easier version (shorter time or distance). Corrections during "stay" training often create anxiety, which makes the behavior worse. Set your puppy up for success with easier challenges.

Training Environment & Tools

Q: What treats work best for training puppies?

A: High-value, small, soft treats work best. Think tiny pieces of cooked chicken, freeze-dried liver, or small commercial training treats. The treat should be something your puppy can eat quickly without chewing extensively. Avoid hard treats or large pieces that disrupt training flow. Each treat should be smaller than your fingernail.

Q: Do I need a clicker for training?

A: Clickers aren't necessary but can be helpful for precise timing. A clicker marks the exact moment your puppy performs the correct behavior. However, enthusiastic verbal praise ("yes!") works just as well for most puppies. If you choose to use a clicker, you'll need to "charge" it first by clicking and immediately giving treats until your puppy associates the sound with rewards.

Q: My puppy gets too excited during training and can't focus. What should I do?

A: Train when your puppy is calm but alert – often before meals or after a moderate play session that's taken the edge off their energy but hasn't exhausted them. If they're too excited during training, take a brief break, do some calm activities, then try again. Some puppies also focus better with slightly lower-value treats that don't create overwhelming excitement.

Timing and Expectations

Q: My 12-week-old puppy seems to forget everything we practiced the day before. Is this normal?

A: Completely normal! Puppy brains are still developing, and they don't retain information the same way adult dogs do. This is why short, frequent practice sessions work better than long, intensive training. Keep practicing consistently – the "forgetting" will decrease as their brain matures and the neural pathways strengthen.

Q: How do I know if my puppy is ready to move from one command to the next?

A: Your puppy is ready for the next command when they respond to the current command correctly 8 out of 10 times in their normal training environment. Don't wait for perfection – 80% reliability is good enough to add the next command while continuing to reinforce the previous ones.

Q: We've been practicing for a week and my puppy still doesn't seem to understand "sit." Should I be worried?

A: Not at all! Some puppies are quick learners, others need more time. Evaluate your technique: Are you moving the treat too fast? Is your puppy too excited or distracted? Are you saying "sit" at the right moment? Sometimes adjusting your approach works better than more repetition. Consider if your puppy might respond better to different treats or training at different times of day.

Troubleshooting Specific Issues

Q: My puppy only responds to commands when other family members aren't around. Why?

A: Your puppy has learned that commands only apply when you're training them. Have other family members practice the same commands using identical words and timing. Start with family members practicing one at a time, then gradually have multiple people present during training. Consistency across all family members is crucial.

Q: My puppy seems afraid when I ask for commands. What should I do?

A: This suggests your training approach may be too intense or intimidating. Lower your voice, get down to your puppy's level, and make training more playful. Ensure you're using positive reinforcement only – no physical corrections or stern tones. Some sensitive puppies need extra gentle approaches. Make training the highlight of their day, not something they endure.

Q: Can I train multiple commands in the same session?

A: For these foundation commands, focus on one primary command per session, but you can briefly practice previously learned commands as warm-up or cool-down. For example, start with a few "sits" they know well, practice the new "stay" command, then end with successful "sits" again. This builds confidence while introducing new concepts.

Recall Training ("Come") Questions

Q: My puppy comes when called inside but ignores me completely outside. How do I fix this?

A: This is the most common recall challenge! Outside environments are exponentially more distracting than your home. Start recall training in a securely fenced yard with minimal distractions, then very gradually add challenges. Never practice recall in unfenced areas until it's 100% reliable in fenced spaces. Consider using a long training leash (15-30 feet) for safety while building outdoor reliability.

Q: My puppy runs away when I call "come." What am I doing wrong?

A: Your puppy has likely learned that "come" predicts something unpleasant – like ending playtime, getting a bath, or being scolded. Stop using "come" for anything negative immediately. Instead, go get your puppy directly when you need to do something they don't enjoy. Rebuild the command by only using "come" for wonderful things like meals, treats, and affection.

Q: How do I teach recall if my puppy is always on leash for safety?

A: Use a long training leash (20-30 feet) in secure areas to practice recall safely. You can also practice indoors in hallways or large rooms, or in securely fenced dog parks during off-peak hours. The key is giving your puppy the experience of choosing to come to you rather than being reeled in like a fish.

Q: Should I chase my puppy if they don't come when called?

A: Never chase! This turns recall into a fun game of keep-away. Instead, try running in the opposite direction while calling their name excitedly – most puppies will chase you. If that doesn't work, calmly go get them without repeating "come." Chasing teaches puppies that not coming leads to an exciting game.

Q: My puppy comes but stops just out of reach. How do I get them to come all the way?

A: This often happens when puppies have been grabbed or corrected after coming when called. Get down to their level, make yourself inviting, and reward them enthusiastically even if they only come partway at first. Gradually shape closer approaches by only rewarding when they come within arm's reach, then eventually only when they come directly to you.

"Down" Command Questions

Q: My puppy will sit but absolutely refuses to lie down. Any suggestions?

A: Some puppies find the down position vulnerable and need extra encouragement. Try training on a comfortable surface like carpet or grass rather than hard floors. Use extra-special treats, and be patient with the luring process. Some puppies respond better to luring the treat under a low table or your outstretched leg, which naturally encourages the down position.

Q: My puppy lies down but immediately pops back up. Is this normal?

A: Very normal! "Down" just means "lie down," not "stay down." Reward the moment their elbows hit the ground, even if they bounce right back up. Once the behavior is reliable, you can add duration by waiting a second longer before rewarding, then gradually building up time.

Q: Should "down" be taught before or after "stay"?

A: Either order works, but many trainers prefer teaching "stay" with "sit" first since sitting is a more natural position for puppies to hold. Once "sit-stay" is solid, "down" becomes easier to teach and you can eventually combine them into "down-stay" for ultimate relaxation training.

"Leave It" Command Questions

Q: My puppy drops the item when I say "leave it" but picks it right back up. What should I do?

A: This means they understand the concept but haven't fully learned impulse control yet. Practice more with the closed-fist exercise until they consistently turn away from your hand when you say "leave it." Also, make sure you're rewarding with something much better than what they're leaving – the alternative needs to be more exciting than the forbidden item.

Q: How is "leave it" different from "drop it"?

A: "Leave it" means "don't touch that in the first place," while "drop it" means "release what's already in your mouth." "Leave it" is preventive, used when your puppy is approaching something forbidden. "Drop it" is corrective, used when they've already picked something up. Both are important, but "leave it" is safer since it prevents the behavior entirely.

Q: My puppy understands "leave it" with treats but not with other items like shoes or toys. Why?

A: Puppies don't automatically generalize commands across different types of objects. You need to practice "leave it" with various items gradually. Start with less tempting objects and work up to highly desirable items like shoes, socks, or favorite toys. Each new type of object requires separate practice sessions.

Q: Is it okay to use "leave it" for interactions with other dogs or people?
A: While "leave it" can be used for inappropriate social interactions, be careful not to create negative associations with other dogs or people. It's often better to redirect attention with their name and "come" rather than making other dogs or people something to "leave." Focus "leave it" primarily on objects and environmental hazards.

"Wait" Command Questions

Q: What's the difference between "wait" and "stay"? Do I need both?

A: Yes, both are useful! "Stay" means "remain in that exact position until I return to release you." "Wait" means "pause briefly until I give permission to proceed." Use "wait" for doorways, before meals, and getting out of cars. Use "stay" for longer periods when you want your puppy to remain in position while you move around.

Q: My puppy breaks the "wait" at doors when they see something exciting outside. How do I fix this?

A: Practice "wait" when there's nothing exciting happening first. Start with interior doors, then boring exterior doors, and gradually work up to exciting situations. If they break the wait, immediately close the door and try again. They'll learn that breaking the wait delays getting what they want.

Q: How long should a "wait" last?

A: "Wait" should be brief – typically 5-30 seconds maximum. It's about creating a pause for safety and manners, not an endurance test. Start with just 2-3 seconds and gradually build up. Most adult dogs rarely need to wait longer than a minute in real-world situations.

Training Schedule & Progress Questions

Q: My puppy seems to learn commands quickly but then forgets them. Is this normal?

A: Absolutely normal! Puppy brains are still developing, and they don't retain information like adult dogs. This is why consistent daily practice is crucial. What looks like "forgetting" is often just incomplete learning – they need more repetitions to make the neural pathways permanent. Keep practicing consistently.

Q: Can I train multiple commands in the same session?

A: For these advanced commands, focus primarily on one new command per session, but briefly practice previously learned commands as warm-up. For example, start with a few reliable "sits," practice the new "come" command, then end with successful "sits" again. This builds confidence while introducing new concepts.

Q: My puppy is progressing faster than the timeline suggests. Should I slow down?

A: If your puppy is truly mastering commands ahead of schedule, you can move faster! Just ensure they're genuinely reliable (responding correctly 8-9 times out of 10) before advancing. Fast learners still need practice in various environments and situations to generalize their learning.

Q: We're behind the suggested timeline. Should I be concerned?

A: Not at all! The timeline is a general guideline, not a strict requirement. Some puppies need more time, especially those who are naturally cautious, easily distracted, or from certain breeds known for independent thinking. Focus on progress, not speed. Solid training takes time.

Multi-Dog Household Questions

Q: My older dog interferes during puppy training sessions. How do I manage this?

A: Separate them during training initially. Use baby gates, crates, or different rooms to create distraction-free zones. Once your puppy responds reliably to commands individually, you can gradually practice with your older dog present at a distance. Some trainers recommend having family members work with each dog simultaneously.

Q: Will my puppy learn faster by watching my older trained dog?

A: Sometimes! Some puppies are excellent observational learners and pick up commands by watching other dogs. However, others become too distracted by their companions to focus on training. Try both approaches – individual training and group observation – to see what works best for your puppy's learning style.

Q: My older dog gets jealous during puppy training. What should I do?

A: Include your older dog with separate training sessions or give them special activities during puppy training time. Puzzle toys, long-lasting chews, or brief individual attention can prevent jealousy. Never let jealousy disrupt puppy training – consistency is too important for your puppy's development.

Behavioral Concerns

Q: My puppy gets overly excited during training and can't focus. How do I calm them down?

A: Train before meals when they're hungry but not after vigorous exercise when they're wound up. If they're too excited during a session, take a brief break for calm activities like gentle petting or simple breathing exercises together. Some puppies need to burn energy with a short walk before they can focus on training.

Q: My puppy seems fearful or stressed during training. What should I change?

A: Immediately make training more positive and less intense. Lower your voice, get down to their level, and use extra-special treats. Shorten sessions to 2-3 minutes and focus on easy successes. Some sensitive puppies need very gentle approaches. If fear persists, consider consulting a positive-reinforcement trainer for personalized guidance.

Q: Is it normal for my puppy to have "off days" where they don't respond well to any commands?

A: Very normal! Puppies have varying energy levels, attention spans, and moods just like people. Growth spurts, changes in routine, or simply being tired can affect performance. On off days, keep sessions very short and stick to easy commands they know well. Don't push through resistance – try again when they're more receptive.

Real-World Application Questions

Q: When can I start practicing these commands in public places?

A: Only after commands are reliable at home and in your yard. Start with quiet public spaces like empty parking lots or calm neighborhood streets during off-peak hours. Gradually work up to busier environments. Your puppy should respond correctly 8-9 times out of 10 in easier environments before adding more distractions.

Q: My puppy obeys me but ignores other family members. How do I fix this?

A: Each family member needs to practice training individually with your puppy. Dogs often bond most strongly with their primary trainer initially. Have other family members take turns leading training sessions using identical commands, timing, and rewards. Consistency across all humans is essential for generalized obedience.

Q: How do I maintain training progress when my puppy goes to daycare or stays with others?

A: Share your command words and training techniques with caregivers. Provide them with the same treats you use and ask them to practice basic commands during the puppy's stay. Inconsistency from caregivers can slow progress, but most puppies can maintain their training with occasional reinforcement from others who understand your methods.

FAQ icons created by Freepik - Flaticon